| 8 | Alan Hutton |
| 7 | James Collins, Richard Dunne, Stilijan Petrow |
| 6 | Gabriel Agbonlahor, Stephen Warnock |
| 4 | Charles N'Zogbia |
| 3 | Emile Heskey, Fabian Delph, Marc Albrighton |
| 2 | Barry Bannan, Carlos Cuéllar, Chris Herd, Ciaran Clark, Eric Lichaj |
| 1 | Darren Bent, Gary Gardner, Samir Carruthers, Shay Given, Stephen Ireland, Andreas Weimann, Brad Guzan, Jermaine Jenas, Nathan Baker, Nathan Delfouneso, Robbie Keane |
